Panelists below from left to right.
Richard Lee, Director of Church Mobilization for International Justice Mission
Tom Countermine, Group Supervisor, United States Department of Homeland Security
David McLaughlin, Founder and CEO at QuantaVerse, LLC
Peter S. Vincent, General Counsel, Thomson Reuters Special Services, LLC
Howard Spieler, Executive Board Member, ACAMS New York Chapter
Human Trafficking: Global Criminal Organization
There remains a pernicious and persistent misconception that criminal and terrorist organizations are run by a group of mouth breathing knuckle draggers, but that’s simply not the case. In fact, the leaders of these transnational criminal organizations are exceptionally sophisticated and savvy operators.
When we underestimate the abilities of international terrorist and criminals, we do so at our own peril. Whilst law enforcement and intelligence agencies—as well as the financial industry—are bound by laws, rules, regulations, policies, and basic notions of ethics and decency, terrorists, criminals, and fraudsters are subject to no such restrictions or morals, and that, unfortunately, gives them a huge advantage. But that is what separates the good guys from the bad guys.
Human Trafficking Statistics
Despite being illegal in every country in the world, and best efforts from many different law enforcement agencies to thwart these criminals, human traffickers earned more in profits last year than the top 13 Fortune 500 companies - combined - $150 billion.
In the United States alone, human trafficking generates $9.5 billion annually.
The average age of a child prostitute in the United States is 12 for girls and 11 for boys.
The average victim may be forced to have sex 20 - 48 times per day.
Indicators of Trafficking for Frontline Banking Personnel
Exhibits fear or anxiety
Exhibits sings that their movements are being controlled
Unable to present passport or other travel or identity documents or have false identity or travel documents
Associated with a high risk industry likely to be used for exploitation
Unfamiliar with the local language or their home or work address
Allow others to speak for them when addressed directly
Act is if they are following instructions from someone else
Cause of Human Trafficking
What we’ve found in the developing world is the lack of adequate law enforcement creates a recipe for enslavement. When laws are enforced and justice systems operate, slavery ends.
The solution to slavery must eventually be accomplished through the existing government and justice system. That is the only way the solution can scale. Only the government has the necessary resources, personnel, and authority needed to end slavery in a community.
The Role of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in Identifying Human Trafficking
The challenges with existing technologies are well documented. Companies know about the false positive rates, but what is less well understood are the amount of false negatives. Theoretically, AI can improve on these results by enabling computers to mimic human knowledge and insight when looking at enormous data sets. Practically, we are proving the ability to find instances of HT that are missed by rules based engines.
The ability to sort through and analyze disparate sets of data, from innumerable sources, to identify patterns, the anomalies to those patterns, and discern whether those anomalies indicate something nefarious is a specific capability.
AI can types of anomalies that aren’t easily identified by legacy technologies. For instance, professional investigators maintain that the lack of information is often an important indicator. This is a type of anomaly that an AI can and should pick up on. Lack of salary, or abnormally low salary payments can be a very clear indication of HT. Of course, just because there isn’t any readily available salary, doesn’t mean there is HT going on, but it can certainly be a point the machine recognizes which causes it to dig deeper in order to resolve that ambiguity.
Also a multi-variate analysis is unique and valuable. The combination of a bar having exorbitant income from liquor sales, while also showing payments for advertising to on-line escort websites, is an example of a machine being able to put pieces of the puzzle together.
Other tools are productivity oriented. This tool “can” provide an answer by mimicking human insight.
Trends and patterns pertaining to the flow of money into and out of bank accounts
Frequent ATM/credit card transactions between 10pm – 6am
Card payments to online escort services (advertising, etc)
Multiple credit cards working in tandem, with suspicious activities spread across accounts
Numerous transactions in even dollar amounts
Value of Using Artificial Intelligence to Combat HT in Financial Transactions
Other tools are productivity oriented. This tool “can” provide an answer by mimicking human insight. The only way to mimic human understanding is with a cognitive engine. While investigators might groan at this answer, the fact is there aren’t enough humans, and budgets aren’t large enough to sort through all the alerts and unflagged transactions in order to find instances of HT. And even if there were enough people, the disparity in talent, training, and motivation of those investigators would be so large as to be ineffective.
The speed and efficiency of this technology will far surpass what is available today.
Other values lie in solving the entity resolution problem, so you have clarity regarding who you’re dealing with.
Ability to discern networks and connections and to diffuse risk across those networks, and HT crimes require a network. An example, not specific to HT, but work we have been doing with an Asian regulator helped them to see the networks, i.e. criminal organizations, that were present in all the SARs that had been submitted to them, but which they hadn’t previously recognized. I have to assume that’s a tremendous benefit to them and to law enforcement.